Humans and Machines Can’t Moderate Alone: Our Hybrid Recommendation

As experts in content moderation technology at Cleanspeak, we're often asked about the role of human moderators in today's automated world. While AI and machine learning have made tremendous advances in content filtering and moderation, the reality is that human moderators remain an essential part of effective content moderation. However, to be truly effective, those human moderators need to be empowered with advanced automated tools.

The Continued Need for Human Judgment

Automated systems, especially those relying heavily (or entirely) on LLM driving AI, have become remarkably good at detecting obvious policy violations like explicit content, hate speech, and spam. However, they struggle with nuance, context, and edge cases which require human-level understanding. Even with the best automated systems, a person must still create the policies and calibrate the tools to what those policies are, or are not.

Some areas automation still struggles with:

• Detecting subtle forms of bullying or harassment
• Understanding sarcasm and irony  
• Evaluating potentially controversial, but legitimate political speech
• Identifying new slang terms or coded language used to evade filters (this requires deep understanding of your community, continuous training of ML models, and/or handing over your data to train LLMs)
• Assessing the intent behind potentially offensive content, or sensitive topics such as suicide, self-harm, grooming, or trafficking.

In these situations, human moderators provide crucial judgment and contextual understanding that machines can't match. You need people who can evaluate content holistically, factoring in user history, community norms, and cultural context. Even with Cleanspeak protecting your community, humans are still key players in your moderation strategy, especially for trickier cases.

The Importance of Community Management with Moderation

Beyond enforcing rules, human moderators play a vital role in actively shaping healthy online communities. They can:

• Tune default settings within toolsets to the specific needs of the community.
• Engage directly with users to explain policies and decisions, fostering your community sentiment while protecting your brand
• Nurture positive community members, rather than only punishing negative members
• Spot emerging trends or nuanced/coded issues within the community, often through reporting and alerting in tools like Cleanspeak
• Provide feedback to improve automated systems and policies and continuously tweak rules, alerts and lists to react faster than training models can

This type of community management is critical for fostering belonging and shared norms, and no automated system can replicate engagement.

Empowering Human Moderators with Advanced Tools

While human moderators are essential, they can face an overwhelming volume of content in today's digital landscape when hundreds, thousands, or even millions of users are creating new content by the minute. This is where advanced moderation tools like Cleanspeak come in.

Cleanspeak’s underlying technology acts as a force multiplier for human moderators by:

• Automatically filtering obvious violations to reduce workload
• Prioritizing borderline content for human review
• Providing rich context and user history to inform decisions
• Identifying both positive and negative behavior within audiences
• Offering customizable workflows to streamline moderation
• Generating insights and analytics to guide strategy
• Surfacing trends and summaries on what is happening in your community

With these tools, human moderators can focus their valuable time and judgment on the most nuanced and impactful cases.

Cleanspeak Recommends a Hybrid Approach

At Cleanspeak, we believe the most effective content moderation combines the scale and consistency of automation with the nuanced judgment of human moderators. Automated systems handle the bulk of straightforward moderation, while human moderators tackle complex edge cases and actively shape community norms.

This hybrid approach allows platforms to maintain amazing communities at scale, while preserving the human touch users expect and trust.

While automation continues to advance rapidly, human moderators remain an irreplaceable part of the equation. By empowering those moderators with cutting-edge tools like Cleanspeak, platforms can achieve the ideal balance of efficiency, accuracy, and community-building in their moderation efforts. It’s a core reason we continually work with, and contract, professional moderators to help guide our product, so we can protect your brand.

‍

Get started on your hybrid approach with Cleanspeak today.